STA Law Firm has a team of settlement experts to represent secured creditors, debtors, trustees, equity holders and suppliers....
Read more informationCorporate Law Firm in UAE-& across MENA. Corporate Lawyers in Dubai...
Read more informationSTA Law firm has a dedicated team of franchise lawyers who advises and counsels the franchise arrangements, structuring franchise programs, franchise network and distribution. ...
Read more informationSTA - Expert Team of Commercial & Contracts Lawyers in Dubai & UAE...
Read more informationSTA Law Firm is one of the leading law firm in Banking and Finance, Capital Markets, DIFC, Compliance and Regulatory practices. ...
Read more informationContact our expert team of property lawyers in Dubai & across UAE....
Read more informationSTA Law Firm's team of employment lawyers in Dubai, Abu Dhabi and across UAE advise universities, engineering & shipping firms, banks, & other industries...
Read more informationIntellectual Property Law Firm. Patent, Trademark Registration UAE...
Read more informationTechnology & Media Law Firm in Dubai - Expert Lawyers...
Read more informationSTA has a dedicated team of fraud & criminal lawyers in Dubai & UAE...
Read more informationShipping Law Firm in Dubai | Offices - Middle East, Asia & Europe....
Read more informationMergers and Acquisitions Law Firm in Dubai and United Arab Emirates...
Read more informationIn today’s competitive business environment the mining industry is becoming a very attractive option for foreign investors. New projects are being launched, but we can appreciate that foreign investors will find the mining industry......
Read more informationSTA lawyers recognize that the healthcare industry comprises of a variety of individuals, professions, teams and organisations that may need our legal services. We have considerable knowledge and experience......
Read more informationClients rely on and trust STA's banking lawyers to take a timely, practical and individually tailored approach to meet specific requirements of our clients. ...
Read more informationInsurance Practice at STA - Expert Insurance Lawyers in Dubai & UAE...
Read more informationSTA is a leading technology and media law firm in Dubai & across UAE...
Read more informationHospitality Lawyers in UAE - Expert Advice to Hospitality Industry...
Read more informationSTA’s seasoned team of property lawyers in Dubai, Abu Dhabi and across the UAE have thorough and extensive knowledge and experience in dealing with construction and real estate law matters. Learn more about our expertise and our team of property lawyers...
Read more informationSTA's lawyers in UAE specialize in all areas of contentious as well as non-contentious discipline in oil and gas industry and advice on both upstream and downstream work. Consult one of our Senior Energy Lawyers in Dubai or other offices today!...
Read more informationCombining variety of practice disciplines to provide extensive advice and counsel to clients, STA’s FMCG practice represents companies in a broad range of industries including large scale franchisors, Fortune 250, and multinationals ...
Read more informationShipping and Maritime Law Firm - UAE, Middle East, Asia and Europe. Expert advice on ship building, ship fiance, sale and purchase, compliance, due diligence and more. Our lawyers advice on all types of vessel including bulk carriers, tankers, cruise ships, offshore rigs and support vessels....
Read more informationSTA's Team of Lawyers in Abu Dhabi, Bahrain, Doha, UAE, Luxembourg, Moscow, RAK, Sharjah, and Singapore. Find a Lawyer. ..
Read more informationChild Slavery Lawsuits Against Nestlé and Cargill Have Been Dismissed by the US Supreme Court
The US Supreme Court overturned a decision that enabled numerous individuals to sue food giants Nestlé USA and Cargill for alleged child enslavement, restricting corporate responsibility under the Alien Tort Statute.
More specifically, in Nestlé USA, Inc. v. Doe I, which was combined with Cargill, Inc. v. Doe I, was decided by the Supreme Court. The anonymous plaintiffs in these instances claimed that Nestlé and Cargill were involved in the exploitation of child slave labour on Ivory Coast cocoa fields.
Even though Nestlé and Cargill did not control the farms, they supplied them with significant resources, including training, tools, and cash. The two businesses were given exclusive rights to acquire cocoa from the plantations in exchange for this. In an 8-1 judgment, the Supreme Court ruled Nestlé and Cargill not responsible for human rights violations on the farm.
The unidentified plaintiffs filed their lawsuits under the Alien Tort Statute. Foreign nationals can sue in US courts for human rights violations committed abroad under the Alien Tort Statute.
The purpose of this law, according to the Supreme Court in Jesner v. Arab Bank, was to “promote harmony in international relations by ensuring foreign plaintiffs a remedy for international-law violations in circumstances where the lack of such a remedy might provoke foreign nations to hold the United States accountable.”
To decide that US law should be applied extraterritorially under the Alien Tort Legislation, the Supreme Court must establish that the statute expressly authorizes such application and that conduct occurred within the United States. Only broad corporate decision-making, according to the plaintiffs, took place in the United States in this case.
As a result, the Supreme Court determined that applying the Alien Tort Statute to Nestlé and Cargill's alleged behaviour in this case would be an unconstitutional, extraterritorial application.
Justice Thomas, supported by Justices Gorsuch and Kavanaugh, argued that the statute's permissible uses of extraterritoriality should be limited to those that would have been recognized in the eighteenth century. Five of the remaining members of the court agreed on the case's outcome, but the court could not reach a consensus on whether the statute's causes of action should be limited.
Moreover, this case will prohibit future human rights violations against companies in which defendants may simply claim that "wide corporate decision making" happened in the United States.